5 Signs Your Small Business Website Needs a Redesign

Joe Fredrick • April 8, 2025

Website Redesign Signs to Look Out For

Is your website feeling more like a deserted digital alley than a bustling storefront? Maybe it's drawing in tumbleweeds instead of customers.

If you're a small business owner in Neenah or anywhere in the Fox Valley, you’re definitely not alone in this struggle. Many local businesses are discovering that their websites just aren’t cutting it anymore.

In today’s digital-first landscape, having a modern and effective website is no longer a nice-to-have—it's a must. For businesses in the Fox Valley, this is especially pressing.

Your website often serves as the first impression for potential customers, and it needs to shine. Think of it as your round-the-clock storefront, your most persuasive salesperson, and a vital link to your local community.

A well-crafted website can help you rise above the competition, attract new customers who are actively searching for what you offer, and ensure a smooth experience for your regulars.

In this blog post, we’ll take a look at the telltale signs that it might be time for a website redesign. Let's dive in!

The 5 Key Signs Your WEbsite Neens a Redesign

Sign #1: It Looks Outdated and Isn't User-friendly

An outdated website can show up in many ways, and each of these can hurt your business’s credibility and turn away potential customers. A website that feels old or neglected can create a negative impression, making it harder for people to trust you or see the value in what you offer. Keeping your online presence fresh and appealing is essential for attracting and retaining customers.

Common signs include:

Clunky Navigation: Is it difficult for visitors to find what they need? Outdated navigation often involves drop-down menus with too many options, making it hard for users to find the information they want quickly.

Outdated Color Schemes and Typography: Are you using color palettes and fonts that were popular in the early 2000s? These can make your site look unprofessional and out of touch.

Poor Layout and Design: An outdated layout might include crowded pages, inconsistent spacing, and a lack of visual hierarchy, making the site look cluttered and unappealing.

Lack of High-Quality Images: Using low-resolution or stock photos that don't reflect your brand can make your website look cheap and unprofessional.

Fredrick Media understands the importance of modern, responsive web design.

We offer:

Modern, Responsive Web Design: We create websites that adapt seamlessly to any screen size, whether it's a desktop, laptop, tablet, or smartphone. This ensures a consistent and enjoyable experience for all visitors.

Seamless User Experience Across All Devices: We focus on creating intuitive navigation, clear layouts, and engaging visuals that work perfectly on every device.

Understanding of Current Design Trends: Our team stays up-to-date on the latest web design trends, ensuring your website has a modern, professional look that will impress your visitors. We can help you choose a color scheme, typography, and imagery that reflects your brand and appeals to your target audience.

Sign #2: It's Slow and Has a Poor User Experience (UX)

A slow-loading website can be a real buzzkill for visitors. In a world that moves at lightning speed, people expect web pages to pop up almost instantly. If your site takes ages to load, they're likely to get frustrated and click away, heading straight to a competitor instead. This is especially true for local folks in Neenah and the Fox Valley who need quick info on their phones.

Moreover, poor user experience (UX) can really push people away. If your website is hard to navigate, confusing, or just not friendly to use, visitors are going to feel overwhelmed and simply leave. It’s all about making sure that your site feels easy and welcoming, so people stick around.

Common UX issues include:

Slow Loading Times: As mentioned, this is a huge issue. Even a few seconds can make a big difference.

Confusing Navigation: Can visitors easily find what they're looking for? If your navigation is cluttered, inconsistent, or illogical, they'll struggle to find the information they need.

Lack of Clear Calls to Action: Are you making it obvious what you want visitors to do? If your calls to action (CTAs) are weak or non-existent, people won't know how to contact you, make a purchase, or learn more.

Poor Readability: Is your content easy to read? Small font sizes, poor contrast, and long paragraphs can make your website a chore to read.

These issues add up to a frustrating experience, which can lead to high bounce rates (the percentage of visitors who leave your site after viewing only one page) and lost opportunities.

Fredrick Media can help you create a website that provides a fast, seamless, and enjoyable experience for your visitors.

We offer:

Website Speed Optimization: We'll optimize your website's code, images, and other elements to ensure it loads quickly.

Intuitive Navigation and Site Structure: We'll design a website that's easy to navigate, with a clear and logical structure.

User-Friendly Design: We'll create a website that's not only visually appealing but also easy to use, ensuring your visitors can find what they need and take the actions you want them to take.

Sign #3: It's Not Generating Leads or Sales

Your website should do more than just look good; it should be an essential part of your business strategy, helping you attract new customers and boost sales. If you find that your website isn't bringing in fresh leads or increasing your revenue, it might be time to think about a redesign.

Often, a website that isn’t effective at generating leads or sales has some common issues to address:

Lack of Clear Calls to Action (CTAs): Are you telling visitors what to do? Do you have prominent buttons that say "Contact Us," "Get a Quote," or "Shop Now"? Weak or missing CTAs mean visitors don't know how to take the next step.

No Lead Capture Forms: Are you collecting visitor information? If you don't have forms for email sign-ups, contact requests, or quote requests, you're missing out on valuable opportunities to connect with potential customers.

Not Designed for Conversion: Is your website designed to guide visitors toward a specific goal? A good website should be structured to make it easy for visitors to make a purchase, request a service, or take another desired action.

Irrelevant or Stale Content: Is your website content up to date and actually useful to your customers? If not, they will leave.

For example, imagine someone in the Fox Valley searching for "local web design services." They find your site, but there's no clear way to request a consultation or see pricing. They'll likely leave and contact a competitor who makes it easier to get in touch.

Fredrick Media can help you turn your website into a lead-generating machine.

We offer:

Strategic Call-to-Action (CTA) Integration: We'll implement clear, compelling CTAs that encourage visitors to take the desired action, whether it's contacting you, requesting a quote, or making a purchase.

Lead Capture Form Implementation: We'll design and integrate effective lead capture forms to help you collect valuable information from potential customers.

Conversion-Focused Design: We'll create a website that's designed to guide visitors through the sales funnel and maximize conversions.

Compelling Content Creation: We can help you craft content that is relevant to your customers and encourages them to take the next step in the buying process.

Sign #4: It's Difficult to Update and Manage

How often do you find yourself saying, "I wish I could just change this text" or "I need to add a new page, but I don't know how"? If you're constantly struggling to update your website, it's a sign that it's difficult to manage.

This usually happens when a website is built on an outdated or complex platform. Small business owners in the Fox Valley need to be able to make quick changes to their websites without having to rely on a developer for every little thing.

Here are some common issues:

Outdated Content Management System (CMS): An old CMS can be clunky, difficult to navigate, and lack the features you need to easily update your site.

Lack of Training or Documentation: Were you properly trained on how to use your website's CMS? If not, you'll likely struggle to make even simple changes.

Reliance on a Developer for Simple Updates: If you find yourself needing to contact a developer each time you want to change a phone number, update a price, or add a blog post, it not only consumes your valuable time but also adds unnecessary costs to your budget.

Fredrick Media believes that website management should be a breeze.

We can help by:

Building Websites on User-Friendly Platforms: We use modern, intuitive CMS platforms like Duda, which make it easy for you to update your content, add pages, and manage your website.

Providing Comprehensive Training and Support: We provide thorough training and ongoing support, so you'll feel confident in your ability to manage your website.

Done-for-You Updates: Our website care plans feature unlimited minor updates, such as adding photos and text. This service is a game-changer for busy business owners who want to keep their content fresh and engaging, all without the stress of handling every little detail themselves. We've got you covered, so you can focus on what you do best.

Sign #5: It's Not Optimized for Search Engines (SEO)

When you're trying to figure out how folks discover businesses like yours in Neenah and throughout the Fox Valley region, it often starts with a simple Google search. If your website isn’t set up to be search engine friendly (that’s SEO), you might miss out on some great local customers who are looking for exactly what you offer. It's all about making sure you’re visible when they need you.

Here's why SEO is crucial for local businesses:

Local Customers Use Search Engines: When people search for products or services "near me" (e.g., "best pizza Neenah" or "plumber in Appleton"), they're ready to buy. If your website doesn't show up in those searches, you're missing out on valuable local business.

Google Prioritizes Local Results: Google's algorithm favors websites that are relevant to the user's location. This means that if you're targeting customers in the Fox Valley, your website needs to be optimized for local search.

So, what makes a website "optimized" for search engines?

Here are a few key factors:

Relevant Keywords: Your website's content should include the words and phrases that people use when searching for your type of business (e.g., "web design Neenah," "local SEO services Fox Valley").

Accurate Business Information: Your business name, address, and phone number (NAP) should be consistent across your website and online directories like Google My Business.

High-Quality Content: Your website should provide valuable, informative content that is relevant to your target audience.

Mobile-Friendly Design: As we discussed earlier, Google prioritizes mobile-friendly websites in search results.

Fast Load Times: A fast website improves user experience and helps with SEO.

Fredrick Media understands the ins and outs of local SEO.

We offer:

SEO-Friendly Web Design: We build websites with SEO best practices in mind from the ground up, ensuring they're structured for optimal search engine visibility.

Local SEO Services: We offer a range of local SEO services to help your business rank higher in local search results, including keyword research, on-page optimization, link building, and Google My Business optimization.

Conclusion

A modern, effective website is crucial for small businesses to thrive, especially here in Neenah and the surrounding Fox Valley area. If you're finding that your website feels outdated, slow, or just isn't bringing in the leads you hoped for, it might be time for a little refresh. An ineffective website can push potential customers away, hurt your search engine rankings, and really impact your bottom line.

At Fredrick Media, we’re passionate about supporting local businesses like yours. We know the challenges you face, and we’re here to help you create a website that not only looks fantastic but also delivers results. Whether it’s through responsive design, easy-to-navigate interfaces, or effective SEO strategies, we offer tailored solutions that fit your unique needs.

Don't let an old website hold your business back from reaching its full potential. Reach out to us at Fredrick Media for a friendly consultation or a website audit. We'll take a look at what you currently have, chat about your goals, and work together to craft a personalized plan to give your online presence a boost.

As a special thank you to our fellow Fox Valley businesses, we’re offering a free website evaluation. This is a great chance to see how your site is performing and learn how we can help you achieve your online goals. We can’t wait to help you grow!

< Older Post

FREE WEBSITE REPORT →

If you want to improve your website's visibility and search success, we recommend starting with the basics first. Request your free website audit now to discover possible issues holding your site back from reaching its full potential!

SEND MY REPORT!